Pros advice

Has the USGA just introduced the most pointless golf rule ever?

We might not like rules when it comes to playing sport, but we’re kind of happy to accept them when they’re logical or work to help players and improve the game overall. However, sometimes a new rule is introduced which is so bizarre, so ridiculous that it borders on idiotic; and golfers have the USGA to thank for the latest pointless new rule, one which comes into effect early next year and states that golfers who choose to play alone can no longer submit scores towards their handicap.

We’ll just let that sink in for a moment…Not good news for golfers in the US, is it…

Effectively the USGA – golf’s governing body – is saying they don’t really trust players to be honest about writing down their actual scores. That perhaps some people tinker with their cards to make themselves look better than they really are.

There are several things making this rule arguably the most pointless ever, not least of which is how hypocritical it is. Golf is a game of honour, one in which players uphold long-held traditions by acting as their own referees during games. Now, apparently, those at the top feel it’s time to stop entrusting people to do that.

Why not just let people lie about their scores? If they’re the kind of person who can’t help but cheat, then let them. Who is it hurting in a game they play alone? Surely once they play alongside another golfer they will be found out anyway, so they end up looking foolish in the long run. And if you try to stop these people, won’t they just do it anyway? Penalising the honest players who just want to play golf by themselves occasionally is wildly unfair.

But there is a deeper issue here. Golf has yet again managed to seclude itself. For the longest time it has struggled to lure a new generation of fans to the greens, either because they deem the costs too high or because the game is played at too slow a pace – it’s a big reason participation numbers keep tumbling. Golf needs more players. But in order to do this, it must make itself accessible to everyone; the exact opposite of what this rule does.

When you make it harder to get a handicap then you push people away from the sport. It’s inconvenient having to play in groups for some people and less fun. How can those players retain an attachment to something which seems intent on shoving them back whenever they approach it open-armed?

And no, this is not repeated in other sports, either. Just golf. It is golf-specific, which makes the new rule all the more painful to accept. OK, most sports don’t have handicaps that need taking into account, but there are comparable situations. The NBA, for example, doesn’t decree that people aren’t allowed to say they made 10-straight free throws in their back garden unless someone else is watching. It’s a matter of believe me or don’t, and it doesn’t get overly complicated.

Golfers have taken to twitter and Facebook to vent their frustration at the new ruling, with some calling out the USGA over a lack of trust.

"This is stupid. Solo golf is fast, if you cheat u just screw yourself for when u play with friends for $$$$," wrote Dan Roth, while Shane McClure added, "How does the usga plan on enforcing this? I doubt your local PGA pro is going to say "Don't enter that score, I saw you play by yourself today!" Right after they check your bag for legal groves and made sure you never anchored your putter!".

While for another Facebook user, Jake Maddens, the USGA's new ruling was the last straw: "my whole handicap is based on playing by myself, so I'm done with golf."

It’s clear that this time the USGA might have overstepped the mark and enforced one ridiculous rule too many…

Keep up to date with all the latest news & videos
Latest News
  • OG News: Rickie Fowler fulfils dying man's golf wish

    Rickie Fowler took to Instagram to share his experience with Dr. Reyes, a man who gallantly battled pancreatic cancer, and made his dying wish come true by dedicating his victory to the man in heart-warming fashion...
    Read more

  • OG News: McIlroy to keep best mate as caddie in 2018

    Four-time major winner Rory McIlroy, who split with his career-long caddie JP Fitzgerald following the Open Championship back in July, has opted to stick with his best friend Harry Diamond as his bagman heading into 2018...
    Read more

  • OG News: Rickie Fowler enjoys record-breaking victory in the Bahamas

    It’s been a week of firsts for Rickie Fowler at the 2017 Hero World Challenge, for the first time in his career shooting 28 on the front nine on his way to a historic victory in the Bahamas...
    Read more
Latest Videos
  • Video: TaylorMade Milled Grind Golf Wedge

    When you're in the scoring zone and you need a golf club to help you score low, then look no further than the Milled Grind wedge from TaylorMade. This fantastic golf wedge has been created from 8620 carbon steel with bronze finish that offers great feel and touch.
    Read more

  • Video: Mizuno MP-18 Steel Irons

    The Mizuno MP-18 steel iron is a throwback to the muscle-backs of the past...
    Read more

  • GolfBuddy WTX GPS Watch

    This lightweight and slim GPS watch displays dynamic green view, hazard and layup points, giving you accurate distance information and insight you need to play the golf course with more confidence. With automatic hole recognition and access to over 40,000 golf courses around the globe.
    Read more